Good morning Savvy Septic readers. Monday night’s Septic Summit work session was reasonably well attended. There were Alpine Wood representatives from Phase I and Phase II, Oversight Group members, ACAT members, residents from Alpine woods who were thinking about enrolling in the program, a local radio station and news reporter, and city staff. Of the guests the City specifically invited, Dr. Mark Gross, an Orenco engineer from Oregon attended; Tom Varney, an Anchorage Tank representative attended; Oran Woolley from the Alaska Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) attended; as well as Bob Tsigonis (a well respected package treatment plant engineer) and the City’s contract engineer from Lanning Engineering, Dave Lanning. King Bee attempted to send their representative, Sheldon Shaw to the meeting but the plane malfunctioned in Fairbanks. Erik Williamson, the author of the University of Anchorage and Jeff Garness, the engineer of the Quanics systems, as well as a variety of other Alaskan Septic Installers were invited but were unfortunately unable to attend. Mike Congel, the local AdvanTex maintenance man, was there to answer any specific maintenance questions.
And now for the numbers we’ve all been waiting for: The effluent results were great! All 6 of the systems tested passed with flying colors. The DEC was very pleased with their performance. Much of the meeting was still spent discussing the temperature of the tanks and whether or not insulation would still be needed but in the end, the DEC and the Orenco Engineer both felt insulation would not be technically necessary although it wouldn’t hurt the program. The City has already purchased the Phase II AdvanTex tanks with insulation but, after a long discussion with the City engineers and the DEC, it was determined that the risk of damaging the pods by installing retrofit blue board insulation was not worth it for Phase I residents. Instead of blue board insulation, the city will continue monitoring the Phase I pods and take several more effluent samples (at different times of the year) to confirm and add to these field results.
Some of the positive notes of the septic summit were:
Valdez systems have had extremely low numbers of alerts, alarms and unscheduled maintenance visits. Tom Varney indicated this was one of the smoothest start-ups he has ever seen and that Mike Congel was as busy as the Maytag Repair man.
The DEC made a chart to compare the AdvanTex effluent with a standard septic system effluent and the City’s Sewer Treatment Plant limits (which are extremely strict because they discharge into the Prince William Sound). The AdvanTex results show the systems performing better than even the Sewer Treatment Plant limits (the lower the numbers, the cleaner the water).

For a copy of the full SGS laboratory report,
click here.
Oversight Group member and ACAT board member Gary Minish pointed out that Alyeska’s ballast water treatment system has been operating at about 38 degrees Fahrenheit for many years and it is a biological system which has worked quite well in Valdez. He made this comparison because of the high AdvanTex effluent quality despite the low temperatures and cool groundwater.
Dr. Mark Gross and his fellow Orenco engineers have been running heat sink models simulating Valdez field conditions for the last two weeks and can provide anyone who is interested with the math and results. Just contact him at (541) 459-4449 or email him at mgross@orenco.com. He is also available for any other technical questions or requests. He spent two weeks reading everything posted on the City website pertaining to the septic project and he listened to the last several Council Meetings on tape prior to his arrival here so that he would be prepared to answer any type of questions we had.
Statistically, to accurately represent the number of systems in Valdez, the City would have only had to test 3 systems. We tested six. Taking into account the samples variability and the margin of error, the City can be confident of the sample results representing a typical system to within 5 mg/L.
As reported in these pages before, Anchorage Tank’s own test results confirmed the independent laboratory results shown here, and Anchorage Tank tested all of the systems (to see a copy of these results
click here).
Bob Tsigonis brought information on his Lifewater package treatment plant systems and made himself available to Alpine Woods residents for questions. We have copies of his information available at City Hall and you can contact him at (907) 458-7024 or email bob@lifewaterengineering.com. Lifewater treatment plants are a great option for anyone who would like to explore alternative to the AdvanTex systems. Although Jeff Garness couldn’t make it to the Septic Summit, several residents picked up his information packets (which we also have available at City hall). These systems are an excellent alternative to AdvanTex systems as well. You can contact him at (907) 337-6179 or email jeff@garnessengineering.com. As the City staff works through its revisions to Option 2 they will bring them forth to the City Council, who can review and approve reimbursement amounts and outlined steps for Option 2. Providing they are approved we will, of course, immediately post the guidelines on the website.
In conclusion
After the Council asked the DEC and the engineers their own questions (mainly were the systems working properly [yes] and does the DEC approve of their installation and operation [yes]) the mayor was kind enough to open up the work session to public input and allow any of the residents present to ask their own questions. By 10 pm most of the questions had wrapped up and when the City Manager asked the Council for direction on how to move forward, the City Council told him to ask Rockwell Engineering (the low bidder for the AdvanTex systems Group A & B) if they would still honor their bid (after 45 days they no longer have to honor it). If they would honor it, the Council requested the City Manager to bring the Rockwell bid back to the Monday City Council Session (July 6th) for action. Lisa spoke with Rockwell Engineering yesterday and they are willing to honor their bid.
Whew! That was a long one. There is a lot of sewage sentiment flowing from City Hall this week. Hopefully it was spellbinding. If you still want more you can listen to the full meeting audio tape on the City Website
here. Thanks to all the readers that attended the Septic Summit. We hope this gave those of you who couldn’t make it a good idea of the meeting highlights. We’ll keep you posted!